
Questions About Charter Schools You Always Wanted Answered
1. What Is a Charter School?A charter school is a public school with a twist. While still accountable for standardized test scores and
adequate yearly progress, charter schools are created with a charter, or a contract that stipulates certain goals the school must achieve, which are normally related to improved academic performance. In addition, charter schools receive funding not only from the state and federal government, but also from other sources, primarily the donations of large philanthropic organizations.
2. How Are Charter Schools Funded, Exactly?
In general, charter schools receive around 60% of the funding that regular public schools receive. From there, they may receive additional funds that have been appropriated specifically for charter schools from local and federal government. For example, in the
2009 budget, the U.S. government has allocated 216 million dollars for charter school grants, out of a total education budget of almost 47 billion dollars. Other major contributions for charter schools come from donations. The largest amount of money for charter schools from such a source comes from
The Walton Family Foundation, run by the family that owns the Wal-Mart Corporation. Other major donors include
The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and the
Broad Foundation. The rest of the money comes from local businesses, parents, smaller donations, and the like.
3. Do Charter Schools Improve Student Performance?
The jury is still out on this question. In the past four to five years, numerous conflicting studies have been published. Some state that students who have come to charter schools from public schools perform better. Other studies, most notably
one released by the National Assessment of Educational Progress, show that overall, charter schools are performing worse than public schools. Some believe that by offering a choice between a regular public school and a charter school creates an environment of competition. Supporters believe that this “ups the ante” for all schools in a district, and
an overall increase of about 1 percent has been shown in test scores for districts in this situation. However, opponents say that the atmosphere of competition creates an antagonistic environment that is detrimental to teacher satisfaction and, by proxy, student performance.
While test scores do offer a quantitative measure of student performance, educational research is at heart qualitative, which makes reliable research very challenging. Too many variables exist for studies to pinpoint exactly whether student performance has improved due to the creation of a charter school. For instance, the following variables could skew figures in charter-school research: the type of students that attend the charter school (low-income, high-income, low-achieving, high-achieving, etc.), the length of time the charter school has been in operation (it normally takes at least two years for a charter school to operate effectively), the amount of money a school has available and how that money is controlled, and the perception people in the community have of the charter.
4. Who Runs Charter Schools?
This is one of the variables that make research on charter-school success difficult. In some cases, the charter school is run by a school district or by a university. In other cases, the school may be run by an organization that oversees a network of charter schools, such as
GreenDot or
KIPP. Whichever model a charter school uses comes with pros and cons. On the one hand, a charter school has a smaller group conducting oversight compared with the mammoth bureaucracy that runs most public schools. On the other hand, opponents of charter schools feel that since a charter school is often run by a board with diverse interests (parents, donors, CEOs), decisions can be made on a self-serving basis instead of for the benefit of students. This is especially true when a charter school is run by a for-profit organization, where in some cases, students who require special services have been denied admission since they are considered “too expensive.”
5. Which Students Attend Charter Schools?
Student bodies at charter schools are often determined by the demographics of the areas in which they are located. Critics have often accused charter schools of serving the interests of higher-income families to the detriment of lower-income families who are left behind at the local public school once a charter is created. However, many charter schools serve low-income neighborhoods and take over low-performing schools with serious discipline problems, such as
Locke High School in Los Angeles. In either case, students are usually selected using a lottery system since spaces is often limited and highly competitive.
6. How Do Teachers Feel About Charter Schools?
Charter schools are widely seen as places where teachers are allowed more freedom in the classroom. To avoid antagonizing teachers’ unions, many charter school organizations strive to maintain good relations with labor organizations, but these are not always “friendly,” which gives teachers pause as they consider moving to charter schools. In one common scenario, when a public school is taken over by a charter organization, the entire faculty and administration can be dismissed and only a fraction may return, after going through the same rigorous interviewing process new applicants are subject to.
7. Can My Child Go to a Charter School?
If there is a charter school in your neighborhood, there is a possibility that your child could attend, based on space available and any lottery system that may be in place. Some charter schools might have requirements for entry, such as tests or grades, if they are designed to bolster a specific subject, like a math and sciences or humanities magnet. Some states (about ten) also do not allow charter schools. If you do not have access to a charter school, various organizations are willing to help you and your community start one.
Further Reading: